Timothy debuted in "LSD: Dream Emulator | Days 1-5 | Scared by Dumbo!".
When naming Timothy, there was some controversy over what name to use. Hoshcof wanted to name him Timothy, but Fedora Wearing Wolf, who was some-what "co-comenntating" with Hoshcof, suggested that he name him "Radical Bobby", a reference not to Bobby, as Hoshcof thought, but to a Creepypasta which Hoshcof had never heard of. Leaving the decision to the Potatoes, it was decided that he would be named Timothy.